A couple of weeks ago, some of my kinmates and I were preparing a run through Great Barrow. We had a group of five that could handle completing the instance, but I tossed out an advertisement in LFF anyway for the last spot because I know there is always someone that wants to complete the quests and cannot find a group. I quickly get a whisper from a Minstrel asking if she could join us. I replied in the affirmative and shortly thereafter we are all having a relaxed and grand old time with the Wights. About halfway through the instance, our new friend says that she is sorry but will have to go AFK because the “doctor has come to my room”. She puts me on follow and we continue, but of course the rest of us are wondering what circumstances brings someone to playing LOTRO while a hospital patient. She returns after a short while, apologizing profusely for the inconvenience. We tell her “No Worries!” and continue. After the run, one of our group members (and our kin leader) continues a private conversation with her and learns that she is 20 years old, her mother died when she was young, her father is not involved in her life, she has no other close friends or family, and is a hospice patient with Stage 4 bone cancer. Her doctor tells her that she has maybe two months left.
Our kin leader communicated this information to us, and being a kind hearted sort, speaks to her again the next day and invites her to join our kin. She accepts and brings her hunter, Gynnie, into our family. We all try to be as friendly and upbeat as we can whenever she logs on, hoping to bring a little sunshine into an otherwise gloomy world. Gynnie and our kin leader strike up a fast friendship and he spends some time chatting with her each day, mostly to let her share her pains with someone. Also, one of our kin officers that had a house next to the kin house gave it to Gynnie since he was planning to upgrade to a deluxe house anyway. She was very excited to be a part of the kin and a resident of our neighborhood
Now, let me confess something right now. Although I am not proud of the fact, I am quite often cynical of new people, particularly those with hard-luck stories. Surely, someone wouldn’t lie about something as grave as this. However, it is not beyond the realm of possibility that an attention starved teen drama queen could play a game like this thinking that no one will get hurt because it all takes place in the imaginary digital world. For the time being I would take her story at face value, but I would watch carefully for inconsistencies/inaccuracies in her story. I REALLY should lighten up sometimes.
Gynnie asked our kin leader if he wanted to be added to her Oncology Advisory Update List (or something like that), to which he agreed. From what I gather, it is a system that provides information about her condition and treatment schedule via email or other means. Gynnie’s nurse also commented that since our kin leader had taken an interest in her life, she had been more willing to cooperate with her treatment. This past Wednesday night, the kin leader asked some of us to be online Thursday evening because Gynnie was going to have a very painful treatment and wanted to know someone was available for her to talk to (he had a previous engagement, would be on, but later). I wasn’t able to log on until about halfway through the four hour process, but Gynnie immediately began sending me tells, they seemed a little frantic, I guess because she was so scared. I tried to calm her by telling her that I have a daughter almost the same age as her. Here is the conversation paraphrased:
Gynnie: “What would you do if your daughter were sick and dying like me?”
Me: “I would do everything possible to make her last days comfortable”
Silence.
Me: “If your Dad were involved in your life, what would you want him to do?”
Gynnie: “I would like to hear that he cared that I was sick, that he would tell me he wouldn’t forget me.”
Me: “A father isn’t required for that, a friend can do that
“
Gynnie: “But a father should offer
“
Gynnie: “and mine never will”
She would also tell me many times that the treatment was horrible and she couldn’t do it anymore. I was at a loss for what to say…”Sure you can!”? Easy for me to say when I’m not the one going through it. Or, “Yeah, you’re right.” ? That’s not what she needed either. I finally settled for, “I’m sorry you are having to go through this. I’ve been praying for you.” Finally, our kin leader logged on and she began to talk with him (don’t blame her, I wasn’t much help or comfort).
Friday and Saturday night were largely incident free as Gynnie mostly spent time talking with our kin leader. Gynnie did whisper me to apologize for “dragging you all into my problems” and disrupting our playing time. I told her that she was a friend and therefore could not be considered a nuisance. Then she brought it up again, “I know I am going to die alone, I just don’t want to be forgotten”. I replied that I have a stellar memory and promised to never forget her. This seemed to comfort her a bit and she didn’t bring it up again.
Sunday afternoon she logged in briefly without really saying much.
Sunday night things went South. Gynnie logged in (with help from her hospice nurse) and immediately got in a group with her new best friend (kin leader). Not too much later, he posts a message in kin chat to the effect of “Gynnie is not able to type, but she wants to say goodbye to everyone. If you want to reply, now is the time.” Wow. So it’s time. Everyone that is on posts as comforting a message as possible and Gynnie’s nurse reads them to her. Then the kin leader says, “She wants to leave her character at her house, I’m explaining to the nurse how to get her there.” I respond, “meet ya there!” and clicked on my travel to Kin House ability. But I wasn’t the first one to arrive. Another officer was sitting in her yard when I arrived, two more kin mates came in right behind me. In a moment the kin leader and Gynnie were in front of us. The nurse (God bless her), held the laptop up so Gynnie could see us with her at her house. Prayers and words of love were typed in kin chat, the nurse reading them to Gynnie as her heart went into an arrythmia and she drifted away. At 7:20 pm PST, she left us and went to rest with God.
And there we were, stunned in Falathorn Homesteads. Gynnie had given everyone in the kinship maintenance privileges to her house for us to do with it what we will. Our will is to keep that house as hers for as long as we play, and plant pretty flowers in her yard. Everytime we run through her yard, it will say “Home of Gynnie”, and we will remember her. And that’s what she wanted. Maybe this blog will be around for years to come and someone will read it and learn about Gynnie, helping to make sure she isn’t forgotten.
Dying young is tragic enough, but dying alone is even worse. I am thankful that we were able to be there (albeit virtually) and provide a little comfort during her last days, but what if she hadn’t met us? It roils my stomach to think of it. Go hug your loved ones and thank God you have them.

(Gynnie is the one facing the house)
UPDATE 06/23/09:
Good news and bad news. The good news is “Gynnie” didn’t die after all. The bad news is my cynicism about people has again been vindicated. The girl in the video is NOT “Gynnie”, and probably has no idea that this was taking place. Therefore I have removed all references to her from this blog post. I have chosen to leave this blog post largely intact because it’s purpose is to chronicle my adventures in LOTRO, and that means both good and bad. This has been a difficult experience and I hope that it doesn’t cause others to be callous in the event that they have contact online with someone who claims to be sick, but maybe they will do more fact checking than we did. Apparently this is a fairly common occurance. My kin acted completely in good faith and from the bottom of our hearts, so we have nothing to be ashamed of and I am proud to call them friends.
June 22, 2009 at 1:12 am
How sad! But so good that you, your kin (and leader) and the game gave her some support in her last times
June 22, 2009 at 1:42 am
Beautifully written post and incredibly moving story. Thanks for sharing.
June 22, 2009 at 1:45 am
This is probably the single most touching thing I have ever read about LOTRO. My thoughts and prayers go out to you and Gynnie.
June 22, 2009 at 4:25 am
Thank you for this.
June 22, 2009 at 9:42 am
Thank you for sharing this moving and wonderful story about how a “online” community CAN make a difference in a persons life.
I will share this with many others and wish to simply say.
Thank you and God bless you and your kin.
June 22, 2009 at 11:42 am
Thanks so much for posting this. I am Padron (said kin leader) in game and I promised her that she would not be forgotten, this helps to know that I am not alone in remembering this amazing young lady.
June 22, 2009 at 1:25 pm
Thank you…
June 22, 2009 at 1:33 pm
My best thoughts go out to her.
Thank you to you for honoring her so well, and to your entire kin for providing her some comfort.
June 22, 2009 at 10:34 pm
Padron here again. I believe everything is on the up-and-up, but as much as I have invested emotionally in this situation, that is a normal response. I will say that I received updates from the nurse in charge of her care and having spoken directly ****** her during the times in question, I have no reason to doubt their validity. I do have some feelers out, with the hopes that someone can confirm her story and perhaps expand upon it for us. I welcome any communication that helps us honor her memory. Thanks
June 23, 2009 at 8:27 am
This was a sad story. When you game, you do not necessarily think about if you’ll ever see these people on again until it is too late. I’m pretty sure it is true. Anyway made up that kind of thing, well bad things will definitely happen to them. What server are you guys on? Would love to stop by and see the house in memory of ******.
June 23, 2009 at 1:16 pm
This was a very sad and moving story,God Bless you all for being there for her in her time of need and how sad that she felt so alone ! That breaks my heart!What game was it that you were playing?
June 23, 2009 at 10:23 pm
The new ‘news’ does not lessen the great act of the kinship, who as most of us have realized, acted in good faith and as a group of uncommonly caring people.
And for that reason, I applaud you all and thank you for being excellent representatives of humankind.
June 24, 2009 at 6:44 am
I found the original story quite moving, but this ‘resolution’ poses so many questions… was your kin targetted? Do you think the intent was malicious? Did she (or he) ask for money or try to scam anything (aside from being given an in-game house)? Was there more than one person perpetrating this? I realise you probably don’t know, so they’re mostly asked rhetorically… it just seems really elaborate for a play for attention, and what was previously a sad story is now a frustrating, unresolved mystery.
Anyway, thanks for the update. Sorry you got duped (though congratulations on your instincts), but it sounds like you acted like paragons, and I hope it hasn’t soured anyone’s experience.
June 24, 2009 at 9:43 am
Everyone in the kinship should be proud of the way they tried to give another person some comfort in what appeared to be their time of need. The compassion you showed is what matters in the end. I know I’m proud to see this kind of thing in the community, no matter how it came about.
Munchhausen by Internet is a fairly common occurrence, and the motivations of the person behind a case are often not malicious. You are probably not the first group of people to encounter this individual, and it probably won’t be the last, but it will be on our servers, if we can help it.
June 24, 2009 at 10:07 am
Patience, does that mean that the account may be banned? Is there an in-game report that we need to make to ensure that it happens? I would love to make sure she’s not able to hurt anyone again in LOTRO.
June 24, 2009 at 7:11 pm
A great post and I learned a new phrase, Munchausen by Internet. You advice still stands though, go hug your family!
June 25, 2009 at 12:35 pm
[...] games | Tags: stupid stupid things, Tolkien, virtual worlds | Leave a Comment I stumbled on this story at a blog I’ve never read before, and – though not surprised – was profoundly [...]
June 25, 2009 at 12:35 pm
It’s sad that there are manipulative people in this world, but it makes me happy to know there are considerate people who would be so kind to someone they hardly know, whether or not that person was deathly ill. You and your friends did a great thing, despite being taken advantage of. You’ve still done a wonderful thing.
June 26, 2009 at 9:16 am
[...] really know? An odd question to be sure. Today (6/26/09) I came across a blog post entitled “Godspeed Gynnie, We Will Miss You“. The post, which was found on the 2 High Road blog, weaves a tale of pain, suffering, and [...]
June 29, 2009 at 9:16 am
[...] is simultaneously a heartbreaking and aggrivating story… and I have no sympathy whatever for folks who do this to trusting [...]
June 29, 2009 at 10:28 am
“My kin acted completely in good faith and from the bottom of our hearts, so we have nothing to be ashamed of and I am proud to call them friends.”
Exactly so. The fact that the person was running some kind of a scam doesn’t take away from your actions in the slightest. Kudos to you and your Kinship!
June 29, 2009 at 11:07 am
That was well done on the part of your kin. I’m sorry your cynicism was reinforced – but it’s worth extending the benefit of the doubt to people who might need your support, even when it turns out like this.
June 29, 2009 at 12:15 pm
If you ever feel like your in some really pathetic hallmark movie, the odds that you are being conned are substantially higher than normal.
September 10, 2009 at 9:54 am
ANOTHER UPDATE: I was recently contacted by someone on my server that was also “Muchausened” by this person. We compared some details and found that the situation was the same in both cases; terminal cancer, ballerina, hospital sounds in the background, daily updates from the oncology nurse (said nurse had same name). Their kin, like us, believed that she had actually died and were planning some sort of memorial or tribute. Date of “death”? Two weeks before Gynnie joined us. Munchausen still isn’t classified as a mental illness, so that simply makes Gynnie a jerk.